Reviews

Manual vs. Automated Review Collection: What's More Effective?

April 25, 2025

Manual vs. Automated Review Collection: What's More Effective?

Customer reviews are a tried and tested form of social proof. They motivate users throughout their purchasing process, assist in establishing brand identity, and even improve search engine rankings. But when it comes to collecting reviews, companies usually have a primary question in mind—should you manually collect reviews or automate the process?

Let's go deep down into both processes and see which one provides better outcomes for your Shopify store.

Manual Review Collection: The Hands-On Method

Manual collection of reviews usually entails contacting customers via email, chat, or follow-up phone calls to gather feedback. Others even use in-person reminders or printed QR codes with review URLs.

Pros:

  • Personal touch: Custom messages can make customers feel valued.
  • Targeted requests: You can ask specific customers for reviews based on their experience.
  • Control over timing and content: You choose when and how to ask.

Cons:

  • Time-consuming: Requires ongoing effort from your team.
  • Limited reach: Not all customers will be contacted.
  • Inconsistency: Human error or delays can affect review collection.

Automated Review Collection: The Scalable Solution

Automated systems trigger review requests after a specific event — like a purchase or delivery. These can be set up to send review request emails without manual input.

Pros:

  • Saves time: Once set up, it runs on autopilot.
  • Higher response rate: Timely prompts reach more customers.
  • Consistency: Ensures every customer is asked for feedback.
  • Integration-ready: Many tools connect with Shopify to sync customer data and events seamlessly.

Cons:

  • Less personalization: Automated messages can feel generic.
  • Requires setup: You need the right tools and configurations.
  • May need refinement: Default templates might not align with your brand tone.

Manual vs. Automated Review Collection: Quick Comparison

Feature Manual Collection Automated Collection
Time & Effort High – requires ongoing manual work Low – runs on autopilot once set up
Consistency Can vary depending on team availability Highly consistent and timely
Scalability Difficult to scale with growing orders Easily scalable for large volumes
Personalization Highly personalized messages possible Limited personalization (template-based)
Reach Limited – not all customers contacted Broad – every customer can be reached
Response Rate Moderate – depends on timing and tone High – due to timely and automated triggers
Setup Required Minimal Requires initial setup and integration
Best For Small stores or VIP customer follow-ups Growing businesses and stores with high volume

Let Rivyo handle your Shopify store review requests automatically

Try Rivyo

So, Which One's More Effective?

Automated review collection typically outperforms manual efforts in terms of volume, consistency, and efficiency. Especially for growing Shopify stores, automation ensures no opportunity is missed. However, combining both can yield even better results — automation for the masses, and manual outreach for loyal or high-value customers.

Supercharge Your Review Strategy with Rivyo

If you’re looking to automate review requests while maintaining flexibility, Rivyo Product Reviews App is a game-changer.

It allows Shopify merchants to:

  • Send automated review request emails after purchase or fulfillment
  • Collect photo reviews and showcase them with style
  • Customize email templates to match your brand voice
  • Import existing reviews from Amazon,AliExpress or CSV
  • Display beautiful review widgets on product pages

Whether you're scaling your store or just starting out, Rivyo helps you turn happy customers into powerful advocates — without the manual hassle.

Final Thoughts

Manual review collection has its charm, but in today’s fast-paced e-commerce world, automation is essential. The key is to find the right balance — automate your core review requests and reserve manual efforts for personalized touches.

Looking to simplify your review collection process? Give Rivyo a try and watch your review count — and conversions — grow.

Rivyo Product Reviews
Try Rivyo or Book a Demo

Boost trust and sales by showcasing authentic product reviews on your Shopify store with Rivyo.

Book a Demo

Recent Blogs

Store Image
Partnership

June 27, 2025

How to Build Emotional Loyalty in a Digital World

Store Image
Partnership

July 23, 2025

Installed Rivyo But Still Have Zero Reviews? Fix It With These Steps

Store Image
Loyalty

July 1, 2025

Product Reviews vs Star Ratings: What Builds More Trust?

Store Image
Loyalty

June 27, 2025

Rivyo Partners with GemPages to Boost Conversions & Trust

Trusted Tech Partners

Rivyo seamlessly integrates with your favorite themes, page builders, and Shopify apps, ensuring a smooth and hassle-free setup. No coding required-enhance your store's functionality effortlessly!

See all Integrations
Tech Image

Get Our Platform for Free and
Get Hold of Special Features!

Take hold of easy navigation, unique information, and tailored experiences at your fingertips. Don't pass up this chance to improve your everyday routine with our free, easy-to-use smartphone app.